Plan
Comptes Rendus

Commentaire & Réponse - Tectonique, Tectonophysique
Reply to comment by El Ouardi et al. on The Cu–Pb–Zn-bearing veins of the Bou Skour deposit (Eastern Anti-Atlas, Morocco): structural control and tectonic evolution
Comptes Rendus. Géoscience, Volume 354 (2022), pp. 125-130.

Résumé

This note is a reply to the « Comment on The Cu-Pb-Zn-bearing veins of the Bou Skour deposit (Eastern Anti-Atlas, Morocco): structural control and tectonic evolution » by Hmidou El Ouardi et al., published in Comptes Rendus Géoscience in Volume 354, 2022, pages 119–123 (https://doi.org/10.5802/crgeos.115). It concerns the article « The Cu-Pb-Zn-bearing veins of the Bou Skour deposit (Eastern Anti-Atlas, Morocco): structural control and tectonic evolution » by Aabi et al., published online on May 04, 2021, in Comptes Rendus Geoscience in Volume 353, 2021, pages 81–99 (https://doi.org/10.5802/crgeos.54).

Métadonnées
Reçu le :
Accepté le :
Publié le :
DOI : 10.5802/crgeos.117
Mots clés : structural model, Copper bearing mineralization, Bouskour, Anti Atlas, Morocco

Ayoub Aabi 1 ; Lahssen Baidder 1 ; Younes Hejja 2 ; Abdellah Nait Bba 3 ; Mohammed El Azmi 2

1 Department of Geology, Faculty of Sciences Ain Chock, Hassan II University, Casablanca, Morocco
2 Managem, Twin Center, Tour A, angle Bd Zerktouni-Abdelkarim Khattabi, Casablanca, Morocco
3 Mohammed I University, Faculty of Sciences, Department of Geology, 60000 Oujda, Morocco
Licence : CC-BY 4.0
Droits d'auteur : Les auteurs conservent leurs droits
@article{CRGEOS_2022__354_G1_125_0,
     author = {Ayoub Aabi and Lahssen Baidder and Younes Hejja and Abdellah Nait Bba and Mohammed El Azmi},
     title = {Reply to comment by {El} {Ouardi} et al. on {\protect\emph{The} {Cu{\textendash}Pb{\textendash}Zn-bearing} veins of the {Bou} {Skour} deposit {(Eastern} {Anti-Atlas,} {Morocco):} structural control and tectonic evolution}},
     journal = {Comptes Rendus. G\'eoscience},
     pages = {125--130},
     publisher = {Acad\'emie des sciences, Paris},
     volume = {354},
     year = {2022},
     doi = {10.5802/crgeos.117},
     language = {en},
}
TY  - JOUR
AU  - Ayoub Aabi
AU  - Lahssen Baidder
AU  - Younes Hejja
AU  - Abdellah Nait Bba
AU  - Mohammed El Azmi
TI  - Reply to comment by El Ouardi et al. on The Cu–Pb–Zn-bearing veins of the Bou Skour deposit (Eastern Anti-Atlas, Morocco): structural control and tectonic evolution
JO  - Comptes Rendus. Géoscience
PY  - 2022
SP  - 125
EP  - 130
VL  - 354
PB  - Académie des sciences, Paris
DO  - 10.5802/crgeos.117
LA  - en
ID  - CRGEOS_2022__354_G1_125_0
ER  - 
%0 Journal Article
%A Ayoub Aabi
%A Lahssen Baidder
%A Younes Hejja
%A Abdellah Nait Bba
%A Mohammed El Azmi
%T Reply to comment by El Ouardi et al. on The Cu–Pb–Zn-bearing veins of the Bou Skour deposit (Eastern Anti-Atlas, Morocco): structural control and tectonic evolution
%J Comptes Rendus. Géoscience
%D 2022
%P 125-130
%V 354
%I Académie des sciences, Paris
%R 10.5802/crgeos.117
%G en
%F CRGEOS_2022__354_G1_125_0
Ayoub Aabi; Lahssen Baidder; Younes Hejja; Abdellah Nait Bba; Mohammed El Azmi. Reply to comment by El Ouardi et al. on The Cu–Pb–Zn-bearing veins of the Bou Skour deposit (Eastern Anti-Atlas, Morocco): structural control and tectonic evolution. Comptes Rendus. Géoscience, Volume 354 (2022), pp. 125-130. doi : 10.5802/crgeos.117. https://comptes-rendus.academie-sciences.fr/geoscience/articles/10.5802/crgeos.117/

Version originale du texte intégral (Proposez une traduction )

1. Introduction

We thank El Ouardi et al. [2021] for the attention they paid to our work on the Bou Skour mineralization and for the discussion they initiated through their comment. Our valuable colleagues have been alarmed by the alleged equivalence between the model we presented for the Bou Skour polymetallic deposit [Aabi et al. 2021] and the model they had previously presented for part of the Bou Skour deposit, namely the Patte d’Oie district [El Ouardi et al. 2016].

In the following, we try to answer point-by-point to the comments by El Ouardi et al. [2021], arguing for the validity of our findings and data, and providing opportunities to clarify some controversial ideas.

2. Structural model of the Bou Skour vein-type deposit

El Ouardi et al. [2021] claim that their proposed structural model of the Bou Skour veins emplacement was omitted [El Ouardi et al. 2016] or appears to have been misunderstood and not cited enough. In addition, they argue that the dextral reactivation of the main vein (Filon Principal: FP) should not disrupt their structural model since the reactivation was documented outside the southern “Patte d’Oie” district of the Bou Skour deposit.

The structural model proposed by El Ouardi et al. [2016] (p. 50) indicates only one kinematics for the Bou Skour shear fault, i.e., a sinistral movement displacing the rhyolitic dykes, and affirms that the emplacement of the mineralized veins postdates that of the dyke swarm. However, based on our field mapping data, there is no evidence confirming this interpretation at the scale of the Bou Skour deposit. On the contrary, we confirmed [Aabi et al. 2021] the occurrence of (at least) a twofold kinematic event (Figure 1A). The first event is a sinistral movement [Figure 1B; cf. Figures 5A–F and 11, Aabi et al. 2021], which is responsible for the vein system formation [574.9 ± 2.4 Ma; Bouabdellah et al. 2016] predating the Ediacaran dyke occurrence [564 ± 7 Ma; Walsh et al. 2008a] and interpreted to be contemporaneous to or immediately postdating the emplacement of the host 570 ± 5 Ma Bou Skour granite [Clavel and Tixeront 1971, Bouabdellah et al. 2016, Aabi et al. 2021]. The second event reactivates the Bou Skour kilometric fault in a dextral brittle regime dissecting a great number of the NNE-trending dyke swarm [Figure 5G,H; cf. Figure 9A, Aabi et al. 2021].

Figure 1.

(A) Interpreted oblique “Google Earth” image of the Bou Skour–Tagmout faulted zone showing the distribution of NE to ENE major faults and their relationship with the NNW-trending Bou Skour mineralized structures. (B) Hydrothermal tension-gashes within the “Filon1” recording the first sinistral movement of the Bou Skour shear zone. (C) Ediacaran rhyolitic dyke dissected along the NNW-FP and its satellite faults showing the right-lateral strike-slip reactivation (southern “Chapeau de Fer” district). See “A” for location.

Contrary to what is suggested by El Ouardi et al. [2021], this polyphase kinematics was not only observed in the northern part of the deposit, but also in its southern part where the dykes are also offset (Figure 1C), which indicates a widespread reactivation throughout the kilometric Bou Skour shear zone. Therefore, the structural model of El Ouardi et al. [2016] was not taken into account and was arguably criticized by Aabi et al. [2021, p. 92].

Furthermore, El Ouardi et al. [2021] argue that the Bou Skour mining district appears to be well studied from a structural, magmatic and geochemical point of view, contrary to what was reported by Aabi et al. [2021].

In fact, in the introduction section of our paper [Aabi et al. 2021, p. 82], we have cited all previous work, including that of El Ouardi et al. [2016], pointing out that their studies have improved the geological knowledge of the deposit and guided the exploration activities in this area up to now. However, the structural analysis remains insufficient as long as El Ouardi et al.’s [2016] work is limited to the southern part of the deposit “Patte d’Oie district” without taking into account the structural framework and tectonic events at the regional scale. Based on our extensive field survey that integrated the available microstructural and geological data, we have provided, for the first time, a new structural map of the entire deposit, thereby upgrading and revising the structural knowledge of this mining area [cf. Figure 4, Aabi et al. 2021].

3. Stratigraphic control and age of the mineralized veins

El Ouardi et al. [2021] explain why their structural study [El Ouardi et al. 2016] was not integrated into a regional and global geodynamic framework by citing the lack of isotopic dates of the Bou Skour mineralization, at that time. They consider that the only stratigraphic marker was the rhyolitic dykes dated at 564 ± 7 Ma [Walsh et al. 2008a]. Instead, crucial well-dated outcrops occur in the southern flank of the Bou Skour district that were already available in the 1:50,000 Bou Skour map [Walsh et al. 2008a]. These outcrops expose conglomerates with interbedded mafic and felsic volcanic formations of the Upper Ouarzazate Group [556–548 Ma; Walsh et al. 2008b] in the hanging wall of the Tagmout normal fault above the rhyolitic dykes and the mineralized structures (NTGF; Figures 1A and 2A,B). This limits the age of mineralization to Ediacaran times and supports the claim that ore emplacement occurred during the latest phase of the Pan-African event [Bouabdellah et al. 2016, Aabi et al. 2021], thus excluding the post-Pan-African, Variscan or Alpine ages proposed by El Ouardi et al. [2016] and by previous authors [Startsyne et al. 1974 −−1975, Harfin 1984, Maacha et al. 2011, El Azmi et al. 2014].

4. Late reactivation of the Bou Skour deposit, implications and conclusion

Figure 2.

 (A) Panoramic view of the southern extension of the Bou Skour mineralized structures as well as the rhyolitic dykes hidden beneath the Upper Ouarzazate Group formations; stereographic representation of normal and strike-slip major structures (equal-angle, lower hemisphere); CF: Clavel Fault, NTGF: North Tagmout Graben Fault, FP: Filon Principal, F1: Filon 1, F2: Filon 2. See Figure 1A for location. (B) Post-mineralization deformation along the NNE-Clavel fault showing a left-lateral strike-slip movement (C) associated with subhorizontal slickensides (D). See Figures 2A and 2B for location of (B) and (C, D), respectively.

The late reactivation of the mineralized structures and any attempt of integration of the Bou Skour tectonics in the regional framework are considered by El Ouardi et al. [2021] as “two subsidiary points” that would not be mentioned to contradict their earlier results [El Ouardi et al. 2016].

However, unraveling the late tectonic evolution and its effect on the mineralized veins in the Bou Skour area should not be considered as a secondary and incidental result, as it makes available a well-described example for a better analysis of the whole Saghro Precambrian domain. As a contribution to our project on the Saghro Massif [Aabi et al. 2017, 2019a,b, Hejja et al. 2020, Hejja 2021], our recently published paper [Aabi et al. 2021] provides new ideas on the Bou Skour ore emplacement and related tectonic events and updates the assessment of its tectono-metallogenic context. The proposed late Pan-African tectonic control of the Bou Skour structures and the related structural criteria may have significant implications for further mining exploration in the wide Precambrian outcrops of the Saghro Massif as well as in the entire Anti-Atlas Pan-African belt. Describing the remobilization and deformation of the Precambrian mineralized structures along the major normal, reverse and strike-slip faults (e.g., Clavel fault; Figure 2A–D) offers a better understanding of the process of fault/vein networks during the superimposed orogenic cycles (Pan-African, Variscan and Alpine) in this part of the West African Craton.

To conclude, in their comment, El Ouardi et al. [2021] do not provide additional detailed fieldwork across the entire deposit than what was presented in their former paper [El Ouardi et al. 2016]. Likewise, they do not take into account the available stratigraphic control of the age of the mineralization [Walsh et al. 2008a,b, 2012, Aabi et al. 2021], and they unduly minimize the interest of unraveling the late regional deformation phases.

Conflicts of interest

Authors have no conflict of interest to declare.

Acknowledgments

Many thanks to the MANAGEM mining group for providing logistical support during the field survey. The authors are very grateful to Professor André Michard (Université Paris-Sud) for his constructive and accurate criticism which helped to improve the quality of this comment’s reply. We also thank the Editors-in-chief, especially Professor François Chabaux for his valuable comments.


Bibliographie

[Aabi et al., 2017] A. Aabi; L. Baidder; Y. Hejja; H. Rhinane; M. El Azmi Post-Pan-African tectonic effect of the Bou Skour-Tagmout mineralization (Eastern Anti-Atlas, Morocco) using remote sensing and structural interpretation, 2nd Colloquim of the International Geoscience Program (IGCP638): 07–15 November, Casablanca-Morocco (2017), 19 pages (Abstract)

[Aabi et al., 2019a] A. Aabi; L. Baidder; A. Nait Bba; Y. Hejja; M. El Azmi; A. Hamzaoui Structural mapping of the Ediacaran western Saghro massif based on aeromagnetic data and field work investigation: implication on post-Pan-African tectonic evolution of the Eastern Anti-Atlas belt, 8th Maghrebian Colloquium of Applied Geophysics (CMAG8): 21–23 March 2019 at Hammamet, Tunisia (2019a), 21 pages (Abstract)

[Aabi et al., 2019b] A. Aabi; Y. Hejja; A. Nait Bba; L. Baidder; A. Bannari; M. Boujamaoui; A. Hamzaoui; M. El Azmi; L. Maacha Structural lineaments mapping and their tectonic significance of the western Saghro massif-Ouarzazate basin contact zone (Anti-Atlas, Morocco): insight from remote-sensing aeromagnetic and field work data, La 11ème edition du colloque Magmatisme, Métamorphisme et Minéralisation Associées (3MA-11) : Avril 23–24, 2019 à El Jadida, Morocco (2019b), pp. 97-98 (Abstract)

[Aabi et al., 2021] A. Aabi; L. Baidder; Y. Hejja; M. El Azmi; A. N. Bba; K. Otmane The Cu–Pb–Zn-bearing veins of the Bou-Skour deposit (Eastern Anti-Atlas, Morocco): structural control and tectonic evolution, C. R. Géosci., Volume 353 (2021) no. 1, pp. 81-99 | DOI

[Bouabdellah et al., 2016] M. Bouabdellah; L. Maacha; M. Jébrak; M. Zouhair Re/Os age determination, lead and sulphur isotope constraints on the origin of the Bouskour Cu–Pb–Zn vein-type deposit (Eastern Anti-Atlas, Morocco) and its relationship to Neoproterozoic granitic magmatism, Mineral Deposits of North Africa (M. Bouabdellah; J. F. Slack, eds.), Springer International Publishing, Cham, Switzerland, 2016, pp. 277-290 | DOI

[Clavel and Tixeront, 1971] M. Clavel; M. Tixeront Une gîte de cuivre filonien, hydrothermal intraplutonique: Bou Skour (Anti-Atlas, Maroc), Notes Mem. Serv. Geol. Maroc, Volume 237 (1971), pp. 203-228

[El Azmi et al., 2014] D. El Azmi; M. Aissa; H. Ouguir; M. L. Mahdoudi; M. El Azmi; A. Ouadjo; M. Zouhair Magmatic context of Bou Skour copper deposit (eastern Anti-Atlas, Morocco): petrogrography, geochemistry and alterations, J. Afr. Earth Sci., Volume 97 (2014), pp. 40-55 | DOI

[El Ouardi et al., 2016] H. El Ouardi; B. Karaoui; A. Mahmoudi; M. El Azmi; M. Zouhair Microtectonic analysis of the copper-bearing deposits of Bouskour mining district at Saghro inlier (Anti Atlas, Morocco), GeoTemas, Volume 16 (2016) no. 1, pp. 113-116

[El Ouardi et al., 2022] H. El Ouardi; B. Karaoui; A. Mahmoudi Comment on The Cu–Pb–Zn-bearing veins of the Bou Skour deposit (Eastern Anti-Atlas, Morocco): structural control and tectonic evolution by Aabi A., et al., C. R. Géosci., Volume 354 (2022), pp. 125-130

[Harfin, 1984] M. Harfin Synthèse géologique préliminaire de Bou Skour, ONA, SMBS, 1984, 32 p pages

[Hejja et al., 2020] Y. Hejja; L. Baidder; H. Ibouh; A. Nait Bba; A. Soulaimani; A. Gaouzi; L. Maacha Fractures distribution and basement–cover interaction in a polytectonic domain: a case study from the Saghro Massif (Eastern Anti-Atlas, Morocco), J. Afr. Earth Sci., Volume 162 (2020), 103694 | DOI

[Hejja, 2021] Y. Hejja Géodynamique de la marge Nord du Craton Ouest Africain de l’Ediacarien terminal à l’Actuel (Saghro, Anti-Atlas, Maroc) : Cycles volcano-plutoniques, tectonique polycyclique et minéralisations, Ph. D. Thesis, Hassan II University Casablanca, Faculty of Sciences Aïn Chok, Casablanca, Morocco (2021) Unpublished Doctoral thesis (Géologie structurale Volcano-stratigraphie)

[Maacha et al., 2011] L. Maacha; A. Ouadjou; M. El Azmi; M. Zouhair; A. Saquaque; A. Alansari; A. Soulaimani Bouskour copper and silver mine (J Saghro inlier, eastern Anti-Atlas), Notes Mem. Serv. Geol. Maroc, Volume 564 (2011), pp. 59-64

[Startsyne et al., 1975] F. V. Startsyne; V. W. Prokhorov; R. J. Sokolov Les caractéristiques géologiques et géochimiques de la bordure sud du gisement cuprifère de Bou Skour (Anti Atlas, Maroc), 1974–1975, 28 pages (Technoexport, Mission géologique)

[Walsh et al., 2008a] G. J. Walsh; F. Benziane; W. C. Burton; A. El Fahssi; A. Yazidi; M. Yazidi; A. Saadane; J. N. AleinikoV; H. Ejjaouani; R. W. Harrison; B. D. Stone; M. Kalai Carte géologique au 1/50 000, Feuille Bou Skour, Notes Mem. Serv. Geol. Maroc, Volume 469 (2008a), 131

[Walsh et al., 2008b] G. J. Walsh; O. Benziane; W. C. Burton; A. Yazidi; A. El Fahssi; M. Yazidi; A. Saadanie; J. N. AleinikoV; H. Ejjaouani; R. W. Harrison; B. Stone Carte Géologique du Maroc au 1/50 000, feuille Bou Skour-Notice explicative, Notes Mem. Serv. Geol. Maroc, Volume 469 (2008b) no. bis, 132

[Walsh et al., 2012] G. J. Walsh; F. Benziane; J. N. AleinikoV; R. W. Harrison; A. Yazidi; W. C. Burton; J. E. Quick; A. Saadane Neoproterozoic tectonic evolution of the Jebel Saghro and Bou Azzer-El Graara inliers, eastern and central Anti-Atlas, Morocco, Precambr. Res., Volume 216 (2012), pp. 23-62 | DOI


Commentaires - Politique