Outline
Comptes Rendus

Sustainable management of fixed dunes: example of a pilot site in Brittany (France)
Comptes Rendus. Biologies, Volume 326 (2003) no. S1, pp. 183-191.

Abstracts

The sand-dunes of Quiberon was chosen as a pilot site to investigate experimentation in conservatory management. Sand burial is necessary to conserve the semi-fixed dune which is a transitory dynamic stage. In the fixed dune, low disturbances benefit the vegetation diversity while heavy ones create serious injury. An opening of the milieu can restore very fast but a naked substrate is difficult to heal. The deposition of gorse branches is then efficient to facilitate the restoration. The fixed dune biodiversity is linked to human activities. Disturbances, natural or not, may be used as management tools.

La dune de Quiberon est un site pilote pour l'étude de la gestion conservatoire. Les apports en sable permettent la conservation de la dune semi-fixée, stade dynamique transitoire. Les perturbations, bénéfiques à la dune fixée quand elles restent modérées, sont préjudiciables à de fortes intensités. La restauration rapide dans le cas d'une ouverture de la végétation devient difficile quand le substrat est mis à nu. Le dépôt de branchages d'ajonc est alors efficace et accélère la restauration. La biodiversité des dunes fixées est liée aux activités humaines. Les perturbations naturelles ou anthropiques doivent servir d'outils à la gestion conservatoire.

Metadata
Published online:
DOI: 10.1016/S1631-0691(03)00056-8
Keywords: sand-dune, vegetation, disturbances, restoration, biodiversity, conservatory management
Mot clés : dune, végétation, perturbations, restauration, biodiversité, gestion conservatoire

Servane Lemauviel 1; Sébastien Gallet 1; Françoise Rozé 1

1 Université de Rennes 1, équipe « Dynamique des communautés », U.M.R. 6553 « ECOBIO », Complexe scientifique de Beaulieu, Bat 14, 35042 Rennes cedex, France
@article{CRBIOL_2003__326_S1_183_0,
     author = {Servane Lemauviel and S\'ebastien Gallet and Fran\c{c}oise Roz\'e},
     title = {Sustainable management of fixed dunes: example of a pilot site in {Brittany} {(France)}},
     journal = {Comptes Rendus. Biologies},
     pages = {183--191},
     publisher = {Elsevier},
     volume = {326},
     number = {S1},
     year = {2003},
     doi = {10.1016/S1631-0691(03)00056-8},
     language = {en},
}
TY  - JOUR
AU  - Servane Lemauviel
AU  - Sébastien Gallet
AU  - Françoise Rozé
TI  - Sustainable management of fixed dunes: example of a pilot site in Brittany (France)
JO  - Comptes Rendus. Biologies
PY  - 2003
SP  - 183
EP  - 191
VL  - 326
IS  - S1
PB  - Elsevier
DO  - 10.1016/S1631-0691(03)00056-8
LA  - en
ID  - CRBIOL_2003__326_S1_183_0
ER  - 
%0 Journal Article
%A Servane Lemauviel
%A Sébastien Gallet
%A Françoise Rozé
%T Sustainable management of fixed dunes: example of a pilot site in Brittany (France)
%J Comptes Rendus. Biologies
%D 2003
%P 183-191
%V 326
%N S1
%I Elsevier
%R 10.1016/S1631-0691(03)00056-8
%G en
%F CRBIOL_2003__326_S1_183_0
Servane Lemauviel; Sébastien Gallet; Françoise Rozé. Sustainable management of fixed dunes: example of a pilot site in Brittany (France). Comptes Rendus. Biologies, Volume 326 (2003) no. S1, pp. 183-191. doi : 10.1016/S1631-0691(03)00056-8. https://comptes-rendus.academie-sciences.fr/biologies/articles/10.1016/S1631-0691(03)00056-8/

Version originale du texte intégral

1 Introduction

The interface between the earth and the sea constitutes a region of great diversity at a physical level and at a biological level [1]. Since a long time, the French Atlantic sand-dunes have been used and exploited. Traditionally, land uses consisted in pasture and sand extraction. They have led to important dune degradations. The fixation of the mobile dune by reprofiling, placing fences, planting marram grass and then afforesting was achieved and has permitted to manage sand movements and to reduce dangers [2,3]. Forestry has then became a way to protect but also the only way to manage sand dunes.

Agriculture and afforestation have modified dune landscapes but at the end of the 20th century tourism is the most destructive human activity affecting coastal areas [4–6]. From resources, dunes have became recreational areas. Many sites have been irreversibly transformed with the construction of seaside resorts, including hotels and apartments on the seafront, campsites and golf courses [7,8].

The Atlantic French dunes are in part the reflect of human activities and can't be considered as a completely natural system. Nevertheless they do have a very high ecological and conservative value as they are very original and rare systems. Fixed dunes which present an important biodiversity at the species and the species community levels are considered as a priority habitat by the European habitat directive [9]. Non forested fixed dunes, now reduced to small fragmented areas, must be conserved.

The conservation of fixed dunes vegetation is a complex aim. It first implies to preserve the vegetation from destructive activities and eventually to restore degraded systems. But fixed dunes are also a dynamic stage and must be manage so as to prevent the development of thickets and the establishment of an older stage in the succession.

The Office National des Forêts (O.N.F.) which manages a great surface of French dunes, have been interested in a better knowledge in dunes ecology and has led European programs (LIFE) located on few dunes. The state-owned sand-dune at Quiberon situated in southern Brittany (France) has been chosen to investigate experimentation in conservatory management and restoration ecology. This article describes the main results of the different experiences concerning some disturbances effects and restoration processes.

2 Material and methods

2.1 The study site

The state-owned sand-dune at Quiberon (southern Brittany, France 47°30′N, 3°10′W) consists of a long dune extending on 25 km [10]. Recognised for its great floristic diversity [11] it possesses one of the largest non-forested fixed dune in France which is inhabited by an association of small geographic range: the Roso-Ephedretum (Kühnholtz Lordat 1923) Vanden Berghen 1958 [12]. This site has been the subject of a European program (LIFE) since 1995 and forms part of the Natura 2000 network [9].

2.2 Experimental device

2.2.1 Monitoring

In order to study restoration mechanisms, effects of disturbances and management experiences, six stations have been chosen in the Quiberon sand-dune for their degradation degree, and enclosed in 1996. The Fig. 1 presents the description of the experimental protocol and the monitoring realised on each station.

Fig. 1

Description and location of the 6 stations in the sand-dune of Quiberon.

The evolution of the vegetation in homogeneous places has been monitored using permanent lines of 100 points [13]. Transects [14] has been used to study restoration processes in heterogeneous places. Transects consist in contiguous 1 m2 quadrats in which vegetation is recorded using Braun-Blanquet coefficients [15].

2.2.2 Experimentation

Rabbit and wind action were simulated in 9 m2 squares, in which 10 quadrats of 30×30 cm were chosen for monitoring using Latin square method. In order to simulate rabbit scraping vegetation was removed and kept in place or exported. A dressing of sand (6.6 kg/m2) was used to evaluate one of the wind effects.

An experimental trampling was applied on two vegetation communities, a semi-fixed dune and a fixed dune, in May, June and September. The protocol consisted in 4 simulated foot paths 10 m long and 1 m wide, delimitated in an homogeneous area. Four trampling treatments were assigned to each of the four foot paths: a control (no trampling) 75, 150 and 300 passages. The vegetation was monitored using permanent lines located in the centre of each path.

Four methods of blow-out restoration were tested and monitored by the phytosociological method. Carex arenaria and Ammophila arenaria individuals were planted in 5×5 m squares every 50 cm. Cypress or gorse branches were used so as to cover the sand in 9 m2 squares.

3 Results

3.1 Effects of disturbances

The exclosures use, to isolate areas from one of the disturbances, didn't provide important results, since the monitoring period was too short. Artificially made disturbances studies were more informative.

Wind appears to be a factor which limits a lot the floristic composition in the semi-fixed dune. After sand burial, no plant can really resist, but Festuca rubra ssp. arenaria and Galium arenarium possess a good regeneration power (Fig. 2). They permit then other species to develop by stabilizing the substrate.

Fig. 2

Evolution of the cover of the principal species after sand burial and in the scraping quadrats with or without exportation of the vegetal material. Means and standard errors.

The analysis of the exclosure effect revealed an important appetite of rabbits for lichens. The opening of the milieu, after scraping, allows a good annuals development and favour Omphalodes littoralis, an endemic species of the French Atlantic shoreline (Fig. 2). The scraping has a positive effect at low level, but it can be detrimental to the specific richness and the cover at a higher intensity (Fig. 2).

Trampling is a complex disturbance as the vegetation response depends on the season (Fig. 3). In particular conditions of intensity and season, this disturbance can benefit to the vegetation cover (Fig. 3).

Fig. 3

Evolution of the relative frequency (RF) of the all vegetation one month and one year after a May, July, or September trampling in a semi-fixed and a fixed dune.

3.2 Restoration processes

Restoration mechanisms depends on the state of degradation. An opening of the vegetation regenerates quickly after disturbances (Fig. 4). When the substrate is naked, restoration appears to be very difficult (Fig. 4). This low process is composed of two successional mechanisms. A colonization with seeds at the centre is realized by Festuca rubra ssp. arenaria in wind-exposed situation or by Erodium cicutarium or Leontodon taraxacoides in more protected conditions. Carex arenaria or Festuca rubra ssp. arenaria spreading abroad the hole margins constitute a second type of colonization.

Fig. 4

Restoration of the vegetation following the stations protection: comparison of two degrees of degradation. Examples of a transect crossing the station “Enclos sud” and a transect crossing the station “Blockhaus”.

Some techniques of restoration have been tested in fixed dune degradations, branches deposition or plantations (Fig. 5). Ammophila arenaria and Carex arenaria plantations permit a good cover, but marram grass limits the specific richness. Branches use, particularly gorse branches were more efficient as it led to a good cover as well as a good floristic diversity.

Fig. 5

Comparison of the efficiency of different techniques of blow-out restoration after two years of experimentation.

4 Discussion

Sand burial is considered as the main factor of the species distribution in a dune system [16]. Festuca rubra ssp. arenaria [17,18] and Galium arenarium are known to be plants well adapted to sand burial and characterize the semi-fixed dune association [12]. The experimental study has shown that this ability come from a good resilience, more than a real resistance. Disturbances are necessary to conserve the semi-fixed dune which is a transitory dynamic stage. Only the sand burial can keep the species Festuca rubra ssp. arenaria and Galium arenarium dominant. An heavy protection of the mobile dune will encourage the closure of the milieu and would reduce the diversity at the community level.

In the dune communities, disturbances such as trampling or rabbit scrapping can benefit to the vegetation in certain conditions of intensity or season. Many authors noticed a positive impact of a moderate grazing or trampling in dry grasslands [7,13,19–24]. They described a limitation of the dominant species allowing less competitive species to develop.

Short dune grasslands morphology is usually attributed to rabbit pressure [25,26]. Boorman and Van der Maarel [27] stressed on the interest of rabbit burrows as an ecological niche for annual species regeneration. It is the case here, notably for the high conservative value species, Omphalodes littoralis which takes advantage of vegetation opening [28].

Trampling can have a positive effect on the vegetation [19]. One year after trampling, the vegetation cover, particularly of the semi-fixed dune, can take advantage of the disturbance. Trampling effects are complex and may result of a two factors balance [13]. The vegetation and soil conditions of humidity seem to be the major factors of the season effect. Trampling damages the vegetation and induce sand movements. At the opposite, soil compaction provides a better stability and also a better humidity for the vegetation [4,29–31].

The disturbance intensity is of great importance [32] while at the higher intensities, trampling or scrapping lead to important degradations, lost of cover and specific richness which are difficult to restore.

The degree of a degradation must be taken into account for the management. Fixed dunes are dynamic systems which response to a degradation can be fast. For example, an opening of the vegetation can completely heal in three or four years since it is protected. But when the vegetation disappear, the soil is eroded and doesn't keep nor organic matter neither seed bank. Healing implies then the beginning of a new succession.

Plantations or branches deposition can be used to accelerate restoration. Marram grass isn't a good tool as it limit the diversity inhibiting the succession and preventing the other species development. Its plantation do not lead to a restoration sensu stricto [33] but to a rehabilitation meaning a stable alternative for the ecosystem. Harvested shoots are known to be a good tool for heathlands restoration [34]. In the fixed dunes gorse branches are particularly efficient as it both permits the best specific richness and the best cover perhaps because of a nitrogen provided of this Fabaceae. This technique can be easily and cheaply realised while material can be collected as part of routine neighbour heathlands management.

Muller [35] proposed three parameters to evaluate biodiversity: richness, equitability and originality. These all components make the fixed dune a vegetation of high biodiversity. Those communities result from a multi-factors action (Fig. 6). Fixed dune is a semi-natural habitat since it is linked to human population for a long time. It implies that disturbances, human activities, wind effects as well as rabbit populations are the sources of the dune biodiversity and must included as tools in management plans.

Fig. 6

Scheme of the dynamics of fixed dunes.

Conservation imply the management of the public pressure and not its exclusion. A too heavy protection would enhance the closure of the milieu, a lost of the diversity and the disappearance of many annual species such as Omphalodes littoralis or Linaria arenaria. Restoration can be actively practiced, but a more efficient conservative management would consist of a survey avoiding heavy degradation and a temporary protection of degraded areas.

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to thank the O.N.F. (Office National des Forêts), plus the C.E.L.R.L. (Conservatoire de l'Espace Littoral and des Rivages Lacustres) and the Fondation d'Entreprise Procter & Gamble France for financial support.


References

[1] P.M. Holligan; W.A. Reiners Predicting the responses of the coastal zone to global change (F.I. Woodward, ed.), The Ecological Consequences of Global Climate Change, Academic Press, London, 1992, pp. 211-255

[2] M. Jacamon Incidences sur la végétation des travaux de fixation et de correction des dunes sur le littoral de Gascogne (J.M. Géhu, ed.), Colloques phytosociologiques, J. Cramer, Vaduz, 1975, pp. 237-244

[3] J.L. Despeyroux La végétation des dune littorales du Golfe de Gascogne, Université de Bordeaux III, Institut de géographie, 1984

[4] M.J. Liddle; P. Greig-Smith A survey of tracks and paths in a sand dune ecosystem. I. Soils, J. Appl. Ecol., Volume 12 (1975), pp. 893-908

[5] R. Paskoff Les dunes du littoral, La Recherche, Volume 212 (1989), pp. 888-895

[6] F. Van der Meulen Dune water catchments in the Netherlands (E. Van der Maarel, ed.), Ecosystems of the World 2C: Dry Coastal Ecosystems, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1997, pp. 533-556

[7] P. Doody Conservation and development of the coastal dunes in Great Britain (F. Van der Meulen; P.D. Jungerius; J.H. Visser, eds.), Perspectives in Coastal Dune Management, SPB Academic Publishing bv, The Hague, 1989, pp. 53-67

[8] E. Van der Maarel; M.B. Usher Recreational use of dry coastal ecosystems (E. Van der Maarel, ed.), Ecosystems of the World 2C: Dry Coastal Ecosystems, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1997, pp. 519-529

[9] C. Romao, Manuel d'interprétation des habitats de l'Union Européenne Version EUR 1, Union Européenne DG6XI-D. 2., 1996

[10] A. Guilcher; B. Hallégouët Coastal dunes in Brittany and their management, J. Coastal Res., Volume 7 (1991) no. 2, pp. 517-533

[11] C. Lahondère; F. Bioret Quelques aspects de la végétation littorale du Morbihan continental, Bull. Soc. Bot. Centre Ouest, Volume 28 (1997), pp. 305-314

[12] J.M. Géhu La végétation côtière. Faits de géosynvicariance Atlantico-Méditerranneene, Bull. Ecol., Volume 17 (1986) no. 3, pp. 179-187

[13] S. Lemauviel, F. Rozé, Response of three plant communities to trampling in sand-dune system in Brittany (France), Env. Manag. (in press)

[14] J.C. Gloaguen; J. Touffet La végétation des landes du cap Fréhel : étude orientée le long de quelques transects, Bot. Rhedonica, Volume 1 (1974), pp. 57-75

[15] J. Braun-Blanquet Plant sociology. The Study of Plant Communities, Hafner Publishing Company, New York, 1965

[16] M.A. Maun; J. Perumal Zonation of vegetation on lacustrine coastal dunes: effects of burial by sand, Ecol. Lett., Volume 2 (1999), pp. 14-18

[17] J.S. Olson; E. Van der Maarel Organic and physical dune building (E. Van der Maarel, ed.), Ecosystems of the World 2C: Dry Coastal Ecosystems, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1997, pp. 63-91

[18] P.D. Jungerius; F. Van der Meulen Aeolian dynamics in relation to vegetation in a blowout complex in the Meijendel dunes, The Netherland, J. Coastal Conserv., Volume 3 (1997), pp. 63-70

[19] E. Van der Maarel Plant species diversity in relation to management (E. Duffey; A.S. Watt, eds.), The Scientific Management of Animal and Plant Communities for Conservation, Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford, 1971, pp. 45-63

[20] H.J. Zeevalking; L.F.M. Fresco Rabbit grazing and species diversity in a dune area, Vegetatio, Volume 35 (1977) no. 3, pp. 193-196

[21] D.G. Milchunas; O.E. Sala; W.K. Lavenroth A generalized model of the effects of grazing by large herbivores on grassland community structure, Am. Nat., Volume 132 (1988) no. 1, pp. 87-106

[22] W.H. Klomp Het Zwanenwater: a dutch dune wetland reserve (F. Van der Meulen; P.D. Jungerius; J. Visser, eds.), Perspectives in Coastal Dune Management, Academic publishing bv, The Hague, 1989, pp. 305-312

[23] R.J. Slatter Ecological effects of trampling on sand dune vegetation, J. of Biol. Educ., Volume 12 (1978) no. 2, pp. 89-96

[24] U.V. Andersen Resistance of danish coastal vegetation types to human trampling, Biol. Conserv., Volume 71 (1995), pp. 223-230

[25] A.S. Thomas Changes in vegetation since the advent of myxomatosis, J. Ecol., Volume 48 (1960), pp. 287-307

[26] F.G. Novo; J. Merino Pattern and process in the dune system of the Donana national park, southwestern Spain (E. Van der Maarel, ed.), Ecosystems of the World 2C: Dry Coastal Ecosystems, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1997, pp. 453-468

[27] L.A. Boorman; E. Van der Maarel Dune grassland (E. Van der Maarel, ed.), Ecosystems of the World 2C: Dry Coastal Ecosystems, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1997, pp. 223-344

[28] F. Bioret; S. Magnanon Inventaire phytocoenotique du littoral de Bretagne et évaluation de l'originalité et de l'intérêt patrimonial des syntaxons d'importance communautaire (G.M. Géhu, ed.), Colloques phytosociologiques XXII. Syntaxonomie typologie des habitats, J. Cramer, Berlin, 1994, pp. 145-181

[29] C.W.P.M. Blom Effects of trampling and soil compaction on the occurrence of some Plantago species in coastal sand dunes, Oecol. Plant., Volume 11 (1976) no. 3, pp. 225-241

[30] C.W.P.M. Blom; L.M.F. Husson; V. Westhoff Effects of trampling and soil compaction on the occurrence of some Plantago species in coastal sand dunes. IVa The vegetation of two dune grasslands in relation to physical soil factors, Botany (1979), pp. 245-259

[31] M.A. Maun Dry coastal ecosystems along the Great Lakes (E. Van der Maarel, ed.), Ecosystems of the World. 2B: Dry Coastal Ecosystems, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1993, pp. 299-316

[32] P. Moreno-Casasola Environmental dynamics and vegetation differentiation in a mexican gulf coast dune area (E. Van der Maarel, ed.), Ecosystems of the World 2C: Dry Coastal Ecosystems, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1997, pp. 469-482

[33] J. Aronson; C. Floret; E. Le Floc'h; C. Ovalle; R. Pontanier Restauration et réhabilitation des écosystèmes dégradés en zones arides et semi-arides. Le vocabulaire et les concepts (R. Pontanier; A. M'Hiri; N. Akrimi; J. Aronson; E. Le Floc'h, eds.), L'homme peut il refaire ce qu'il a défait?, John Libbey Eurotext, Paris, 1995, pp. 11-29

[34] R.F. Pywell; N.R. Webb; P.D. Putwain Harvested heather shoots as a resource for heathland restoration, Biol. Conserv., Volume 75 (1996), pp. 247-254

[35] S. Muller Biodiversité et gestion des écosystèmes prairiaux : déterminisme et évolution de la biodiversité dans les écosystèmes prairiaux, Acta Bot. Gallica, Volume 143 (1996), pp. 233-238


Comments - Policy